The Sangguniang Panlalawigan committee on environmental protection will bring the conflict on the Manupali River between the National Irrigation Administration (NIA) and the Lapanday Diversified Products Corp. to the province’s multipartite monitoring team (MMT) for investigation.
Provincial board members have summoned the two following NIA’s complaint that the firm was clogging a canal in Dalaingon Creek. Lapanday denied the charges.
The deliberation on July 22, however, was considered an executive session only for lack of quorum. Only seven of the 14 members were present.
The board decided to pass the matter to the committee level for further study. Board member Glenn Peduche, who chairs the committee and also concurrent head of the MMT, said the MMT is the proper forum for investigation.
He said they would find out if LPDC has violated the terms of its environmental clearance certificate (ECC).
The firm claimed the logs that clogged the NIA’s North Main Canal are not theirs.
Gaudencio Ramos, NIA irrigation superintendent, however, said LPDC was responsible for the clogging, citing witnesses that the logs were from the area developed by the firm.
He said the Dalaingon Creek was struck with waterburst (buhawi) and the damage to the clogged dam now has worsened, prompting them to propose a P7-million rehabilitation, instead of an earlier program of work worth only P5 million.
Clogging caused Bangcud flooding?
He said the clogging caused the heavy flooding downstream in Cabangahan and Bangcud when heavy rains fell earlier due to “buhawi”.
Pollution control officer Francis Potestas said at the time they cleared the area adjacent to the creek, they only found small logs. The small logs could not have caused the clogging since their 4.5-hectare land previously planted to corn and sugarcane is just adjacent to Dalaingon Creek, where the canal is. He denied the firm was responsible for the clogging.
He added they aren’t “washing our hands” and are in fact cooperative on a move of the barangay government of Bugcaon to mediate and discuss solutions to the problem with other firms operating in the area.
But he stressed the canals are too small to accommodate volume of water coming from above the area.
Board member Camilo Pepito told the session LPDC should look at the issue as a shared responsibility.
Later the board members proposed to let the MMT find out the crux of the matter. Board member Nemesio Beltran Jr. referred to Peduche if they have done inspection of the area to know the truth considering the two parties are already trading accusations.
Where’s the general manager?
Board member Roland Deticio also balked at the absence of LPDC general manager Luis Alvarado, who instead sent two deputies to the session.
Joanne Caspillo, from the firm’s support services department, told board members Alvarado was with LPDC’s vice president in a meeting scheduled “long before” the SP’s invitation.
“Why did he schedule that meeting today? Why? Are we second class citizens here? He preferred that meeting over us? There is a valid concern here that concerns the welfare of the people,” Deticio said.
“The meeting has been scheduled long before. And we apologize for that,” Caspillo said.
“Tell him to apologize here, we can schedule another session. We will expect him here,” Deticio said.
Earlier, NIA had called the attention of LPDC on the clogging of drainage in Dalaingon, Lantapan due to three logs allegedly uprooted by the firm’s bulldozer operating in the area.
But the firm’s management denied the allegation, saying they have never developed the area referred to. They have likewise asked that their firm “should not be singled out for every unfavorable events or occurrences in the vicinity”.
To shed light on this public concern, the provincial board, upon motion of Deticio, summoned the two organizations to be present at the regular session of the SP on July 15, then later moved on July 22
Deticio cited the public domain of the matter being discussed that’s why the request to be present during the session.
Ramos wrote the LDPC on June 17 asking the firm to clear the clog.
“With the above information, and if found true, it is hereby advised that your company should make urgent action in clearing the drainage to constrain further damages,” he said.
Ramos said the clogging caused water level to rise at the drainage, overflowing to the road and the canal support.
“It was noted that damages of our roads / canals started when your company commenced operation thereat and if not rectified immediately delivery of irrigation water supply to Bangcud area might suffer,” Ramos wrote in the letter.
‘It means higher cost for NIA’
He said NIA has set a P7-million rehabilitation program to repair recent damages. If the firm “will not cooperate” so the budget will not be enough, he added.
LDPC contested NIA’s report.
Luis Alvarado, LDPC general manager, and Caspillo said in their reply letter on June 26 they have never “touched or developed” the 13-hectare property beside the upper portion of Dalaingon Creek in Brgy. Bugcaon, Lantapan town for a year since leasing it in 2008.
But they admitted developing a three-hectare land downstream of the creek “but it was more than a year ago already”.
“We cannot take credence to the above cited report,” Alvarado said in the letter.
LDPC officials added that records will also bear that even before they developed the Bugcaon area, there were already “voluminous” water passing through NIA drainages “which as time passes by might have damaged the roads and berm of your canals”.
They also cited the overflowing water coming from the uplands of Bugcaon during heavy rain “obviously, is also contributory”.
“It should be emphasized that there are other farm holders or companies in the area adjacent to our operations,” LDPC officials said. They said there were issues and concerns lobbed at them that are beyond their control.
But the firm admitted they sent personnel to closely coordinate with the barangay government on clearing drainages as pt of their “corporate social responsibility” as community member.
They said last week, they sent people to clean the clogged area in Zone 6 in Bugcaon village. Deticio added that another reason why they have to summon them is on the issue of flooding in Aglayan, Malaybalay City.
Peduche said the probe is important to ensure the firm will be penalized if alleged violations are proven. (This story also appeared at www.mindanews.com)